Fantastic Four: First Steps just might be Marvel’s most pro-family movie yet. The bond between Reed and Susan Richards is rock solid, and the joy they share as they prepare to have their first child is heart-warming. Along with Susan’s younger brother Johnny Storm and Reed’s best friend Ben Grimm, the Four make a tight-knit family unit, going to great lengths to protect Baby Franklin — and their fellow citizens of Earth — from existential threats. The movie’s core message is heard in Susan’s words as she describes why the Four work so well together: “It’s about fighting for something bigger than yourself,” she says. “Whatever life throws at us, we’ll face it together, as a family.”

But just as the credits roll and we’re ready to declare the movie a real winner, along comes a curveball in the bonus scene that may leave us scratching our heads. It’s now a year later, and Sue is reading The Hungry Caterpillar to Franklin in their living room. When Baby asks for more, Mom calls to H.E.R.B.I.E, the family’s helpful robotic assistant, to fetch another book to read. We see H.E.R.B.I.E hold up an old copy of Charles Darwin’s famous 19th century volume On The Origin of Species. Mom says that’s not the book she’s looking for, but comments that they love reading that one too. Having found the story she had in mind, Sue returns to the living room and, in typical Marvel fashion, the scene concludes with a little foreshadowing to set up the next installment.

Wait a second. Origin of Species for story time?

At first, it may seem like a natural fit. Mr. Fantastic is a polymath, highly skilled in physics, biology and chemistry, as well as mathematics and engineering. He specializes in harnessing science and technology to help the Four solve difficult problems. He’s a confident scientist, but he’s also curious and humble, and at times, ready to admit to forces beyond his understanding. Reed would certainly have respect for Darwin’s accomplishments as a scientist, and that’s probably good enough reason to keep a copy of Darwin’s book around the house. But if any superhero team would be skeptical of a purely Darwinian view of life, it would be the Fantastic Four. Let’s look at why their experiences don’t match the expectations of Darwinian materialism.

Throughout the movie, the Four demonstrate countless examples of sacrificial love and commitment to a higher purpose. Reed and Susan deny themselves regularly for the greater good. Johnny Storm is often the first to leap into the path of danger, even willing to die for others if necessary, and Ben is about as selfless as they come. But in a world where life is the result of chance processes like unguided natural selection and random mutations, things like love and purpose are merely social constructs, irrelevant to the struggle for life. Life boils down to survival and power, qualities that are actually espoused by the Four’s formidable foe, Galactus. No purpose means no value, and no value means no moral order. But the Fantastic Four act like human lives and relationships have inherent worth, not just a utilitarian function. Their willingness to suffer and even die for one another and for strangers only makes sense in a universe where life and love have meaning beyond survival.

The lives of this remarkable family also revolve around a universe teeming with intelligent design. The Four contend with their fair share of intelligent beings, from the Silver Surfer, a humanoid alien from the planet Zenn-La, to the mighty Galactus, who devours whole planets in his quest to survive. And alternate dimensions, portals, and even multiple universes suggest a cosmos rich in order. Yet a materialistic worldview contends that the universe is self-contained and closed to outside influence. This would require that there is no such thing as a supernatural being, force, or cause that influences the universe.

So what caused all life in the Marvel universe to exist? Our findings on Planet Earth may yield an important clue. Here, Darwin’s selection/mutation mechanism has been carefully tested in the last century and found wanting. It doesn’t have the creative power or the time to produce the information necessary to power the origin and development of life. And along with our discovery that information runs the show in biology, we’ve also found, based on our uniform and repeated experience, that the only known cause of information is intelligence. The conclusion? A designing intelligence played a role in the history of life. Could it be the same elsewhere? Given his commitment to the quest for scientific truth, Mr. Fantastic would certainly be willing to entertain the notion.

After all they’ve witnessed in their many adventures, it seems unlikely that the Fantastic Four would have a strong commitment to scientific materialism. Perhaps they keep Darwin’s book around as a cautionary tale, a way to teach their children that scientific hubris can blind us to the wonder and order of the universe with dangerous and far-reaching consequences. If so, maybe Darwin’s Origin of Species does belong on the shelf next to The Hungry Caterpillar after all.

* * *

Andrew McDiarmid is a Senior Fellow and Director of Podcasting at the Discovery Institute. His writing has appeared in the New York Post, San Francisco Chronicle, Daily Wire, and elsewhere. Follow him on X at @amcdiarmid or visit andrewmcdiarmid.org.

The views expressed in this piece are those of the author and do not necessarily represent those of The Daily Wire.